Prom
Controversy Escalates
By Laura Gidley, Reporter
As prom season approaches, tension between the junior and senior classes
is rising, and a war of words continues over who should have the final
say on prom decisions.
The premise of these arguments is based on the senior class's claim
that it was deprived of a fair opportunity to vote on the theme, colors
and a song for the dance.
Traditionally, issues concerning prom are voted upon during a Cougar
TV presentation, in which the entire senior class would fill out
a scantron ballot to vote. This process provided samples of the
color and music selections for the students.
This year, however, the junior class prom committee, in charge
of organizing and hosting the dance, decided that it would take
an alternate route. After a week of advertising on the morning announcements,
a table was set up during lunch in the red hall on the second floor
where both juniors and seniors could vote. The selection process
lasted three days, and did not include as many musical choices as
in previous years, nor did it provide clips of the song choices.
In addition, the prom committee decided not to continue the tradition
of a prom color, and instead opted to give the dance a theme, "Midnight
Masquerade."
The modifications to the voting procedures stirred up controversy
and created a division between the classes. A number of seniors
believed that many people had not heard the announcements and did
not know where or when to vote. Many also felt that the junior class
should not have a say in deciding the prom theme and song.
"The only people who knew about the voting eat in the red
hall," senior Katie Fawley says, "and that's not even
close to half of the people who would want to vote."
Members of the junior class prom committee said that changes to
the voting process were made because the committee believed that
only those who truly cared about the decorations and theme would
make the effort to vote. They thought that those who were uninterested
would not waste their time.
"I talked to [Principal Daniel] Shea about everything we did,
and he said that we weren't doing anything wrong," junior prom
committee leader Fiona Read says. "There are no real rules
on how to organize prom or how to vote."
Besides the organization of the voting process, the prom committee
has made other alterations to prom preparations. This year was the
first time that juniors were allowed to vote on the theme, which
will be displayed May 30 at the Indian Springs County Club. Members
of the prom committee decided that it was only fair to have both
classes vote, since the junior class would be creating and putting
together the dance, as well as attending it. Since they are planning
the dance, they felt that they should have a say in some decisions.
Read believes that the use of a theme instead of colors was an
attempt to make the dance more unique. "We don't want prom
to be like any old school dance," she says.
It will be interesting to see how things unfold as the dance approaches.
Will the seniors and juniors reconcile their differences? Will this
year's theme of "Midnight Masquerade" and the selected
song I Will Always Love You, by Whitney Houston, be a success? For
good or ill, this dance is sure to set new precedents for all future
QO proms.
|