BAND:
The Most Competitive Sport at QO
Jenn Benton, Reporter
They are set apart from everyone else, but they couldn't care less.
They sit in their "reserved" red hallway every day at lunch.
Their closest friends are in that one group. They travel together,
have inside jokes together, and occasionally throw food or yell at
one another. The QO music department is one big happy family.
Still, it's easy to misjudge band and orchestra looking in from
the outside. One of the most common stereotypes is the term "band
geeks" (even though most band members would be proud to be
called that). People automatically assume that the music department
is all about concerts in the auditorium and performances at half
times. Outsiders fail to realize the competitive side of QO Music.
A tradition of competitions between people who are in either the
band or the orchestra has always been a part of QO. Now, don't get
the wrong idea. It is not some sort of race, or a game where someone
tries to score the most points like in sports. It is called a challenge,
and is similar in style to challenges in other competitive areas.
Essentially, it gives musicians the chance to prove to the music
director that they deserve to be placed above another student who
has a better chair, or rank, than the challenger. The competitors
have four days to practice the same song, chosen by director Bill
Hollin. They then play the piece to be judged by Hollin, and whoever
performs better wins the chair.
The most sought after chairs are, of course, the first and second
chairs, which are specially assigned to the best performers in the
class, and receive solos and duets.
"I believe that every student has a right to better their
position," Hollin says. "Though for some students it's
a stressful situation, competition is how the world works outside
of high school, whether you're trying to get a job, get a promotion,
or raise your salary. My job is to help students prepare for the
world outside of high school. And, most importantly, for the better
of the band, it insures that they are practicing and not slacking
off."
The challenge itself is actually more intense than it may seem.
A challenge is emotionally and mentally demanding; it requires physical
preparation just as much as musical proficiency.
The opponents have to be clear-minded and not quick to give up,
especially if they make a mistake. Nerves can also kick in, because
the opponents have no support; the only people allowed in the room
where the challenge takes place are those directly involved (the
challenger, his/her opponent, and the judge).
"It's really hard once you get in there because it's all up
to you," sophomore Jen Chiswell says.
Of course, as in most competitions, a tie can occur. When this
happens, both musicians must then play another song unrehearsed,
simply by sight-reading.
There are also rules on challenging; for example, one student can
only challenge another three times.
The purpose of challenges is not just to inspire competition among
students in the music department. As much as music can be fun and
even educational, it is essential for the department to know what
kind of talent its students possess. Additionally, the challenge
system provides student musicians with more than one opportunity
to try for a top chair.
"It's good because an audition doesn't depict a person's ability
to play the instrument," senior Ho Chiang Wang says. "It
just shows how they're playing at that day and time."
Although some students object to the challenge system, claiming
that it causes too much stress, its advantages are numerous. It
benefits the players to be able to better their rank; band and orchestra
members also see it as something fun, as something to shake the
routine up a little so that the music classes don't become repetitive.
And besides, it breaks the stereotype that music is not as challenging
and competitive as other activities.
|